Thank you for your patience while we bring you new properties each day while we are in development.

Main Content

Fire Island Homes for Sale


Sort by:
  •  
  • Address
  • Price
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • Lot Size
  • 300 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $995,000


    MLS Number: 3397556
    5 3 60
    Taxes: 6417.23

    Exclusive Listing! MLS Number 3397556 Unique opportunity to own a stunning mid century Pines compound just 8 minutes from the harbor. Set on an oversized lot behind a dense screen of foliage and dotted with mature holly trees, this sprawling 3-structure Pines original features 5 beds, 3 ba [...]

    Details
  • 338 Shell Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    5 3
    Taxes: 7576

    Pines Modernism meets 2001 A Space Odyssey in this classic Earl Combs “octagon” house. The upstairs contains open plan living areas including fireplace & outdoor treetop dining terrace as well as master suite. The downstairs houses a den and 2 guest rooms. Enormous pool deck with hot tub a [...]

    Details
  • 514 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $1,685,000

    3 3.5
    Taxes: 2000

    Brand new custom built construction & fully winterized home. This home offers 3 private deck spaces with a dipping pool, redwood cabinetry, open concept chefs kitchen, 2 entry way atrium & spectacular ocean & bay views from the roof top deck with a the potential for a large rental return.

    Details
  • 112 Scaup Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $995,000

    4 2
    Taxes: 4009

    Check out this classic Pines home located close to town and the beach! This split level house offers an open floor plan upstairs for entertainment along with 4 bedrooms downstairs. Step out back onto your expansive decks and enjoy summer by the pool! Suit for rentals or private use, this house [...]

    Details
  • 249 Bay Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $2,800,000

    3 3
    Taxes: 12881

    Bayfront compound designed by Bromley Caldari Architects. Peace and serenity abound as you enter the double height Great Room with unobstructed views of the Great South Bay. Sumptuous Master Suite occupies the entire second floor. 2 additional guest suites. Set amidst natural gardens. Thi [...]

    Details
  • 114 Ocean Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $975,000


    MLS Number: 3361855
    4 2
    Taxes: 4,555.53

    Location, Location, Location! This 2-story four bedroom contemporary home boasts ocean views, hardwood floors and a wrap around deck made out of cedar that allows total privacy with room for a pool. A rare find in the Pines and is move in ready. MLS ID: 3361855

    Details
  • 169 Cedar Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $725,000


    MLS Number: 3352963
    2 1.5
    Taxes: 2232

    This Fire Island Pines cottage is an original home that built back in the 1950s. This charming home has many original features that make the home feel like a true beach house. This home is a piece of pines history and is the first time the home is on the market. This listing courtesy of [...]

    Details
  • 406 Ocean Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $2,295,000


    MLS Number: 3347103
    4 3
    Taxes: 8665.63

    New Exclusive Listing! Welcome to your stunning oceanfront oasis beautifully situated on the east side of the fire island pines. This elegant contemporary home sits in between two lots that cannot be built on. The home is filled with expansive decks on the upper and lower parts of the house [...]

    Details
  • 488 Tarpon Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $1,459,000

    3 4
    Taxes: 7387

    A Beautiful wooden masterpiece inside and out! This unique home is handsomely perched on a large corner lot surrounded by beautiful landscaping on the east side of Fire Island Pines. This home boasts a spacious open floor plan, hardwood floors, high ceilings and has large bay windows throug [...]

    Details
1 2 3 4