Fire Island Homes for Sale

Horace Gifford “tree house”. This 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom, dramatically set at the eastern edge of the Pines, is truly a one-of-a-kind residence. A spiral staircase leads you above the trees into the breathtaking, glass enclosed Great Room. Multi level decking allows for both large sca [...]

$2,450,000

Welcome to 2 Spatenga Walk, a magnificent beachfront oasis, situated on a high dune in the exclusive Water Island Community. This spectacular home is located in a private enclave of only 4 homes. Float into your dock and enjoy the walk up to paradise. This quintessential oceanfront was cust [...]

Check out this stunning bay front cottage located in Water Island. Water Island is a private part of Fire Island with approximately 50 houses. This bay front Fire Island home is a classic cottage and a must see! Listing Courtesy of Belzak and Bodkin Realty Corp.

$875,000

Rare opportunity for bay front property in a quiet Fire Island Community known as Water Island. With approximately 50 houses in the community, Water Island offers peace and quiet while enjoying your time on Fire Island. Enjoy sunny afternoons on the ocean and watch amazing sunsets over the Gre [...]

$922,000

A ranch style home awaits you in Fire Island Pines, New York. This single-family residence has many bedrooms and sits on a good size lot with pool. If you blink it will be sold. This is a great opportunity to put your finishing touches on this gem. Don't miss this unique chance to say ''hell [...]

This classic Fire Island Pines home is situated on a corner lot, surrounded by mature landscaping. This home has an open floor plan and features hardwood floors, and a screened in porch where you will find views of the Great South Bay.

$1,685,000

New custom built construction; fully winterized home. This home boasts 3 deck spaces with a dipping pool that offers the upmost privacy. Inside you will find redwood cabinetry, open concept chefs kitchen that leads into your dining and entertainment area, 2 entry way atrium and 3 bedrooms all [...]

$1,825,000

Intelligently reimagined design by Rodman Paul Architects. Earl Combs’ towering ziggurat remains one of the most iconic mid-century oceanfront homes on Fire Island. Newly configured with 3 bedrooms & 3.5 Bathrooms set around a soaring 3 story atrium, the property is being offered with fully [...]

This 3 bedroom Gem is just steps to town. Some of the highlights of this beautiful pines home include a large heated pool, hot tub and canopy outdoor living space with all day sun on the pool deck. Large living room with fireplace. Separate dining room. Gourmet kitchen. Great master suite wi [...]