Thank you for your patience while we bring you new properties each day while we are in development.

Main Content

Fire Island Homes for Sale


Sort by:
  •  
  • Address
  • Price
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • Lot Size
  • 179A #8 & 9 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782
    MLS Number: 3257918
    1 1
    Insurance cost per year Maintenance cost (for co-op listings): $750.00 per month

    This beautifully appointed one bedroom unit in the iconic Grove Manor is close to the harbor and the beach. Designer's own home boasts Italian marble floors and counter top. Newly renovated and tastefully decorated in high style. Enjoy the ease of co-op living with a salt water heated pool and [...]

    Details
  • 249 Bay Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $2,800,000

    3 3
    Taxes: $12,881

    Gorgeous Bay front modern home! This will be sure to take your breath away! Peace and serenity abound as you enter the double height Great Room with unobstructed views of the Great South Bay. Sumptuous Master Suite occupies the entire second floor. 2 additional guest suites. Set amidst nat [...]

    Details
  • 337 Shell Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $2,000,000

    5 4
    Taxes: $8,549

    This one of a kind, family sized and unusually large 5 bedroom, 4 bath has been completely renovated to the highest standard. Ultra private, comfortable and beautifully finished, this contemporary home features an open gourmet kitchen / dining area that leads onto large pool deck complete with [...]

    Details
  • 479 Tarpon walk , Fire Islands Pines,

    $849,000

    3 2
    Taxes: 5,155

    NEW D Katen Co-Exclusive Classic Pines home in a private setting. Featuring open living room with high ceilings. Open Kitchen with separate dining area that leads out to large pool deck perfect for outdoor entertaining. This a a Co-Exclusive with Vinnie Petrarca Real Estate [...]

    Details
  • 505 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $1,325,000

    3 2
    Taxes: $6,553.21

    Welcome to the stylish side of Beach living! Step through the gates into this beautifully manicured garden and breath a sigh of relief! The stunning landscaping welcomes you home to this 3 bedroom, 2 bath immaculate home. The gorgeous natural wood floors present optimal living and entertai [...]

    Details
  • 140 Lewis Walk, Cherry Grove,

    $1,375,000

    4 4 3,485
    Taxes: $6,292

    Fully Winterized Oceanfront Home.... Just steps to town. A legal two family which can be enjoyed as an income producer with private entrance to lovely two bedroom two bath apartment, or enjoy the space as your guest cottage on the ocean. Newly renovated and finely appointed with att [...]

    Details
  • 75 Bay Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782

    $2,150,000


    MLS Number: 3238323
    3 3

    As soon as you walk through the impressive Gate House you’re met with the lush front garden of this amazing 3 bedroom , 3 bath Bayfront home. Then enter into the gracious foyer to the large double height living room with its massive skylight. The second floor master suite with amazing bay v [...]

    Details
  • 423 Ocean Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York 11782

    $2,250,000


    MLS Number: 3226265
    3 3 8,712

    Latest Exclusive! This 3 bed, 3 bath ocean front is an architectural and design masterpiece. Enjoy ocean views from every room, large open floor plan for easy entertaining, solar htd. pool cradled by mahogany decking, mature and lush exterior garden, irrigation system, hot tub on the roof, co [...]

    Details
  • 236 Bay Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York 11782

    $3,200,000

    8 8.5

    Amazing waterfront investment opportunity. Sitting on the largest bay front lot in the Pines, this 8 bedroom, 8.5 bath, stunner is newly remodeled and turn key ready! Taxes: $16,000.00 Flood Insurance: $10,800.00 Fire & Liability Insurance: $11,000.00 Listing courtesy of Sotheby's

    Details
1 2 3 4 8