Thank you for your patience while we bring you new properties each day while we are in development.

Main Content

Seasonal Rentals

Sort by:
  • Address
  • Price
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • Lot Size
  • 300 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    MLS Number: 3397556
    5 3 60
    Taxes: 6417.23

    Unique opportunity to own a stunning mid century Pines compound just 8 minutes from the harbor. Set on an oversized lot behind a dense screen of foliage and dotted with mature holly trees, this sprawling 3-structure Pines original features 5 beds, 3 baths, an enormous sunny deck with several e [...]

  • 378 Nautilus Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    3 3.5

    Welcome to your newly renovated Fire Island retreat! This 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom home boasts charming character and modern comforts, with a state-of-the-art kitchen and brand new flooring and appliances. Outside, you'll find great outdoor spaces perfect for relaxing, along with a rejuvenating h [...]

  • 303 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    4 2

    This stunning Pines home is the perfect getaway to enjoy your summer on Fire Island. Step into this very private home and you are greeted with Large Windows that open the space up and also overlooks the pool, 4 bedrooms and an open concept floor plan that is ideal for entertaining. Now offerin [...]

  • C255 Harbor Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    2 2

    This Newly renovated 2 bedroom Co-Op is available as a monthly rental! This unit boasts a newly renovated kitchen, 2 bathrooms, high ceilings and large windows that allow for an abundance of natural light to come in. Step outside to your very own private balcony and enjoy the amazing views of [...]

  • 236 Beach Hill Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York 11782
    7 8

    This spacious 7 bedroom 8 bath home is perfect for all your needs RENT & STAY Whether looking for a quarter-share this summer or a limited stay, the house is a perfect place to unwind and enjoy The Pines. FUNDRAISERS & EVENTS The traditional host of The Fire Island Dance Festival, [...]

  • 91 Teal Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    4 4
    Taxes: 8609

    Brand New for 2023! This 4 Bedroom 4 Bathroom oasis is just 2 walks from the Harbor. 91 Teal boasts a brand new chefs kitchen, formal dining and living areas, high ceilings, natural light, 2 ensuite bathrooms, 2 bathrooms with a jack and jill bathroom and A/C in every bedroom. Outside you can [...]

  • 12 Ocean Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    3 3.5
    Taxes: 7972

    Stylish and contemporary, this home offers an open floor plan with cathedral ceilings and 2 story windows throughout the first floor. In the spirit of a true Pines Beach house, there are walls of knotty pine throughout, a roof deck with panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South [...]

  • 137 Doctors Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    2 1 80

    This historic house is on the rental market for the first time since it was built in 1940. It features two bedrooms, A/C, Wifi, back deck, and a front porch. It is located one house from the beach. You can't get more classic Fire Island than this house. Who wants to be the the first to o [...]

  • 90 Gerard Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    0 1

    Check out this Beautiful Studio available for a full season in 2022! This amazing property is just a quick 90 minute trip from New York City to the beautiful located in the heart of Cherry Grove.

1 2 3 4 12