Thank you for your patience while we bring you new properties each day while we are in development.

Main Content

Cherry Grove Rentals

Sort by:
  • Address
  • Price
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • Lot Size
  • 120 Duryea Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    2 1

    This lovely cottage is located in the heart of Cherry Grove and offers tons of privacy. This property is close to town and all the amenities that Cherry Grove has to offer! Contact your agent for weekly availability.

  • 137 Doctors Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    2 1 80

    This historic house is on the rental market for the first time since it was built in 1940. It features two bedrooms, A/C, Wifi, back deck, and a front porch. It is located one house from the beach. You can't get more classic Fire Island than this house. Who wants to be the the first to o [...]

  • 90 Gerard Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    0 1

    Check out this Beautiful Studio available for a full season in 2022! This amazing property is just a quick 90 minute trip from New York City to the beautiful located in the heart of Cherry Grove.

  • 194 Surf Walk , Cherry Grove, New York 11782
    MLS Number: 3345743
    2 1
    Taxes: 3164

    This Cherry Grove Cottage is located at the West End of Cherry Grove. This Stunning 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom home is the perfect place to spend your Summer vacation on Fire Island. This home offers an open floor plan that boasts natural light as well a large outdoor deck space, your own pool and [...]

  • 169 Main Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    2 1

    Check out this wonderful 2 bedroom, 1 bath home in Cherry Grove! Very spacious layout with an amazing outdoor space.

  • 43 Maryland Walk, Cherry Grove , New York 11782
    4 3
    Taxes: 5,719

    This easy maintenance, four bedroom, three bathroom Eberhardt house sits in the middle of a lovely and quiet street, six walks east of the Cherry Grove dock. It features a huge kitchen with granite countertops, an electric range, dishwasher, and microwave. Bamboo floors are found throughout [...]

  • 172 Main Walk - Cherry Grove , Cherry Grove, New York 11782
    2 1

    Available for shares & weeklies 2023! Beautiful 2 bedroom 1 bath cottage with open concept living, cathedral ceilings - combining the charm of original woodwork with superb modern finishes. The house is freshly renovated, with a gorgeous new heated salt water pool, large exceptional outdo [...]

1 2