Thank you for your patience while we bring you new properties each day while we are in development.

Main Content

Cherry Grove Seasonal Rentals

Sort by:
  • Address
  • Price
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • Lot Size
  • 378 Nautilus Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782


    3 3.5

    Brand new construction and ready for shares! This 3 bedroom 3 bath home sits on a beach access walk with state of the art kitchen, all new flooring, decking, and appliances. Shares available for 2022: July 4th Memorial Day Also available weekly in August and Sept. Call for schedule [...]

  • C255 Harbor Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782


    2 2

    This Newly renovated 2 bedroom Co-Op is available as a full season rental! This unit boasts a newly renovated kitchen, 2 bathrooms, high ceilings and large windows that allow for an abundance of natural light to come in. Step outside to your very own private balcony and enjoy the amazing views [...]

  • 236 Beach Hill Walk, Fire Island Pines, New York 11782
    7 8

    This spacious 7 bedroom 8 bath home is perfect for all your needs RENT & STAY Whether looking for a quarter-share this summer or a limited stay, the house is a perfect place to unwind and enjoy The Pines. FUNDRAISERS & EVENTS The traditional host of The Fire Island Dance Festival, [...]

  • 137 Doctors Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    2 1 80

    This historic house is on the rental market for the first time since it was built in 1940. It features two bedrooms, A/C, Wifi, back deck, and a front porch. It is located one house from the beach. You can't get more classic Fire Island than this house. Who wants to be the the first to o [...]

  • 90 Gerard Walk, Cherry Grove, New York 11782


    0 1

    Check out this Beautiful Studio available for a full season in 2022! This amazing property is just a quick 90 minute trip from New York City to the beautiful located in the heart of Cherry Grove.

  • 340-1 Shell Walk, Fire Islands Pines, 11782
    1 1

    This quaint 1 bedroom 1 bath unit has glorious ocean views. Wonderful for a couple or just a single tenant. The interior is furnished handsomely and offers a clean seamless living space. Please note this is a unit attached to a single family home.

  • 303 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Islands Pines,


    4 2
    Taxes: 7900

    Perfect for First time buyers or investors. This Classic Pines Contemporary has a great open floor plan . Large living area with vaulted ceilings . Open kitchen and dining area . Large Sunny Pool and deck area perfect for outdoor entertaining . Four equal Bedrooms share two full baths [...]

  • 510 Fishermans Path, Fire Islands Pines,
    5 5

    This beautiful bay front oasis boasts 5 spacious bedrooms, 4 en suite private baths and 1 shared bathroom. Keep warm by the wood burning fireplace or enjoy the full house air conditioning. The kitchen is fit for entertaining complete with 2 dishwashers and an ice maker. Hot Tub is O [...]

  • 409 ocean Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782
    1 1

    Stylish One Bedroom Apartment with ocean breezes. Spacious Living area , Full Kitchen with Refrigerator with Icemaker , Dishwasher , Shared Laundry . Perfect for one couple .

1 2 3 10