Fire Island Homes for Sale

$2,995,000

Fire Island Pines Oceanfront Landmark House. Grand Living Room opens directly onto the heated pool with the Atlantic Ocean behind it. Impressive Dining Room. Gourmet Kitchen with expensive appliances. High ceilings throughout. Two primary suites with ocean views open onto the pool. Three addit [...]

$375,000

This rarely available corner one-bedroom unit has come on to the market. This is the most sought after floor plan in the co-ops. Large corner sunny terrace. Chefs kitchen, Washer .Dryer. Steps to Ocean and close to town. Enjoy carefree living at the Fire Island Pines Co-ops.

$950,000

Nestled in the quaint community of Cherry Grove, this delightful bayfront cottage offers a unique blend of charm and potential. With stunning water views and a cozy atmosphere, this home invites you to unwind and enjoy the serene surroundings. The quaint interior exudes warmth, with well-maint [...]

$1,500,000

Introducing your DREAM beachside retreat in Fire Island Pines! Nestled amidst lush gardens, this classic beach house boasts 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a design that's straight out of your seaside fantasies. With walls of glass, you'll bask in the natural light and enjoy breathtaking views of t [...]

Welcome to 436 Ocean, an exquisite architect-designed private compound situated behind a large dune on the East End of the Pines. Following a comprehensive renovation, this home blends modern luxury with breathtaking natural beauty. Five spacious bedrooms (three king-sized and two queen-siz [...]

$1,600,000

Beautifully renovated midcentury. 4 large bedrooms. Sun filled open living, dining kitchen. Extra large, all day sun pool deck with hot tub. Extraordinary rent roll. Listing Courtesy of Vinnie Petrarca Real Estate

This beautifully restored mid century is the last word in casual beach living . Situated on a deep ,private lot . Open chefs kitchen featuring bosch appliances . New HVAC . Professional furnishings throughout. Will have a Hot Tub in summer of 2025 Check in Thursday 6pm - Check out Thu [...]

$1,325,000

Welcome to 218 Bay Walk...A Jewel Box in The Pines...Fully winterized during the 2008 total Reno (Top 2 Bottom)...A true oasis of comfort and sophistication, this custom 2 bedroom 2 bath boasts, fireplace, solar heated pool, glorious master suite with custom Versace-style grandeur, custom kitc [...]

$1,725,000

Welcome to this Fire Island retreat on located on Bay Walk, where chic style meets contemporary comfort in a turnkey home that's sure to impress. This remodeled property is a private oasis that includes a heated pool, hot tub, outdoor shower, outdoor fireplace and outdoor dining terrace. As yo [...]