Thank you for your patience while we bring you new properties each day while we are in development.

Main Content


Sort by:
  • Address
  • Price
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • Lot Size
  • Grove Manor 8 Cherry Grove,
    1 0

    This 1 bedroom condo in Cherry Grove is available for no more than 2 people with a Queen bed in bedroom and fold-out couch in living room. The Grove Manor, a small, friendly co-op w/a shared heated pool. Located steps from town & the beach & yet quiet at night! Rentals are Fri. - Fri. No pets [...]

  • 279 Bay Walk, Sayville, New York 11782


    4 3

    Welcome to this Fire Island retreat on located on Bay Walk, where chic style meets contemporary comfort in a turnkey home that's sure to impress. This remodeled property is a private oasis that includes a heated pool, hot tub, outdoor shower, outdoor fireplace and outdoor dining terrace. As yo [...]

  • 179 Ocean Wallk #11 Fire Islands Pines,
    MLS Number: 3467171
    0 1

    Corner studio co-op at the beautiful Grove Manor! Poolside, main floor with heat & A/C. New heated shared salt-water pool, common laundry room, attractive shared deck furnishings. Monthly maintenance $400. Non-Smoking Premises Pet Friendly This listing is courtesy of ASPR

  • 236 Cherry Grove - Fire Island,
    MLS Number: 3455417
    3 1

    Three Bedroom summer cottage with open living-dining room, galley kitchen and 4th room for office or smaller bedroom. Bright sunny deck with washer/dryer shed. This house is located on the lovely West End of Cherry Grove and is only 4 houses off the beach! This listing is courtesy of ASPR

  • 85 Gerard Walk Cherry Grove Fire Island,
    MLS Number: 3467150
    2 1

    Renovated 2018, Outdoor Deck Space, Salt Water Pool "NEW" (fully renovated) 1940's cottage with a large, oasis-like large private yard. Perched mid-block on one of the highest points in Cherry Grove, every inch of this charming 2 bedroom, 1 bath home was reimagined and rebuilt in 2018. Ful [...]

  • C123 Fire Islands Pines,
    0 1

    Perfectly located between the Atlantic Ocean and the Pines Harbor. Come hear the ocean from this rarely available large studio apartment with separate sleeping alcove. Your guest could enjoy the very comfortable Room and Board leather sofa bed. Bright and breezy. Recently renovated with top of [...]

  • 185 Holly Walk Cherry Grove,
    MLS Number: 3459984
    0 0 50
    Taxes: 400.

    This beauty is a buildable 50 x 80 lot awaiting construction of your future beach home, with proper permits. In Cherry Grove and close to town, beach, ferry, restaurants, and nightlife. This location is ideal and offers the rare opportunity to own one of the last lots in Cherry Grove. A great [...]

  • 574 Coastguard Walk, Fire Islands Pines, New York 11782


    4 2
    Taxes: 11355.80

    Step into this historic Horace Gifford home. This 4 bedroom, 2 bath Pines classic is calling your name! A midcentury westside home includes hardwood floors, high ceilings and walls of glass. This home includes a pool, hot tub, and breathtaking views from the roof top deck of the ocean we love! [...]

  • 628 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Island Pines, New York 11782


    MLS Number: 3558.15
    3 2

    Welcome to 628 Fire Island Blvd, a meticulously cared for and renovated Mid-Century Gem with easy access to the beach. This bright house sits on an oversized corner lot with privacy. Once inside, you’re welcomed by open concept living and dining areas with high ceilings, walls of glass and [...]

1 2 3 36