Welcome to the Pines…

Simplicity. Privacy. Luxury. Taste.

Take a look at some of the choices d. katen fire island properties. ltd. can offer you in attaining the perfect island retreat in America’s premier gay travel resort. Whether you’re searching for a fabulous party experience, a seasonal escape or a home of your very own, we can show you the way to your perfect Fire Island rental

We’re here to help you find what you’re looking for.

New Listing

  • 39 Lone Hill Walk

    Spoil Yourself with our latest Exclusive! Wake Up And Start Your Day In This Stunning...

    590 Fire Island Blvd

    This MLS Exclusive Is Nestled On The West Side Of Fire Island Pines And Boasts...

    $879,000.00
    $6,500 / Weekly

    267-1 Bay Walk

    Private Cottage, with a full bed, A/C and private Bath. Has it’s own grill for...

    $1,400.00 / Weekly
  • 270 Floral Walk

    Come spend a week in the Pines in this charming home . Large open living...

    $5,500 / Weekly


Hottest Property List

Our property list is constantly updated to include new and beautiful destinations for your vacation.


Competitive Market Prices

We pride ourselves on offering the finest Fire Island rental properties available on Fire Island, all at the most competitive prices.

List With Us


Guaranteed Service

You’ll feel pampered and relaxed all throughout your vacation with our attentive customer service.

 Fire Island Rentals

An LGBT+ Hotspot

For years, Fire Island has held a historical reputation of being a gorgeous LGBT+ retreat. A large part of its appeal is the ferry ride that transports you there, so you can leave technology behind. There are always exciting events and parties, as well as delicious restaurants located central to luxurious Fire Island rentals.

Fire Island is also a relaxing destination, as you simply won’t have to worry about keeping a schedule. You’ll join the natural flow of the crowd from low tea to high tea, often followed by partying.

fire island rentals
Our Beautiful Properties

The Fire Island Pines provides a tranquil experience with beautiful amenities. You’ll experience the full luxury of a Fire Island rental vacation home right in the heart of the Pines. Our properties make it easy to relax poolside or cook in a full kitchen when in-between events.

Don’t limit your vacation to a simple hotel room; instead, choose one of our fine properties for your vacation. You’ll be fully immersed in everything the Pines has to offer. Explore Fire Island beach rentals from Fire Island Properties. Offering the perfect island retreat in America’s premier gay travel resort. 631-597-7000